As your Servant goes to attack the creature, you notice from your swarm that your servant acts a little erratically, but in unison, the critters inside shake their heads and proceed to spit acid at the creature. (The attack roll is a nat 1! Cannot be re-rolled!)
Their spit is wildly inaccurate, hitting a fire escape which falls down and blocks the alley, making it hard to shoot ranged attacks at the creature just as the other fellow pulls out their gun. It doesn't matter though, as they are unable to pull the trigger, instead holding their head in confusion. "What... Are these... Voices!?"
Before you can answer, the creature jumps over the debris and attacks the man, grappling him with its tentacles as he spits out some blood.
What do you do?